West Somerset MP: badger cull only option to fight TB

West Somerset MP Ian Liddell-Grainger West Somerset MP Ian Liddell-Grainger

FREE shooting of thousands of badgers in West Somerset is the only option for dealing with bovine TB, says the district’s MP.

Natural England has issued licences for culling badgers in pilot zones in West Somerset and West Gloucestershire in a bid to tackle the spread of TB in livestock, which has cost the farming industry an estimated £500million in the last decade.

Each licence lasts for four years and authorises certain people within each area to kill badgers over a six-week period annually between June 1 and January 31.

At least 2,081 badgers, but no more than 2,162 – or 70% of the population in the West Somerset zone, which spans between 150 to 350 square kilometres – must be killed.

West Somerset MP Ian Liddell-Grainger said: “TB has spiralled out of control, we had to kill stock and compensate farmers for 35,000 cattle last year – and we’re getting some serious questions from Europe as to when we are going to start tackling the disease.

“Culling is really the only tool in the box at the moment. A vaccine for cattle is still ten, maybe 15 years away, and if we wait that long there will be very few cattle left to inject.

“One day we may be able to bring a multi-faceted operation to bear onTB but that day is a long way off yet.

“We are reduced to firefighting with an operation which is less than perfect but which in reality offers the only real means we have of making inroads againstthis ghastly disease which, let’s not forget, is fatalto badgers as well.

“Clearly if anyone has any concerns about the cull I shall be more than happy to hear from them.”

But animal welfare groups are opposed to the scheme and say vaccination is the way forward.

Badger Trust chairman David Williams said: “Thousands of healthy badgers will die or be wounded in a night-time fusillade of rifle fire that will kill and wound and put members of the public at real risk.

“And for what? At best a minimal reduction in bovine TB levels over nine years, a time span which could see huge advances in vaccination – for cattle and badgers – and the emergence of a scientifically validated bTB control mechanism.

“Bit by bit [Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs] Owen Paterson’s case for badger culling is falling apart under independent scientific scrutiny.

“We see the slaughter of an iconic previously protected indigenous British mammal as a speculative, irresponsible, politically driven decision which will inflame public opinion and cause immense damage to the reputation of Britain’s farmers.

“We will continue to oppose this appalling decision by every legal means possible.”

Comments(6)

FreeSpeech? says...
9:32am Fri 8 Mar 13

Just goes to show how ill-informed the MPs in this country truly are.

oopsispiltmygravy says...
4:19pm Fri 8 Mar 13

I have often wondered why West Somerset has been blessed with two of the greatest disasters to befall any region......the Badger Cull AND the hapless Liddell-Grainger.

Spectrum says...
4:24pm Fri 8 Mar 13

It is nonsense to claim that this is the "only tool in the box". Just look at Defra's expectations if they are allowed to kill tens of thousands of badgers. Their forecast "benefit" is a 12-16 per cent reduction in nine years. That leaves 84 per cent of the problem untouched. Clearly there are other much more important issues that need tackling if bTB is to be beaten--and the scientists have spelt them out: more effective and more regular testing of cattle (the skin test is only 80 per cent effective); widespread biosecurity (ie disease prevention measures)--most farmers ignore them; much tighter controls over cattle movements. The ineffective test means that thousands of cattle carry the disease and they pass it on to other cattle. Independent scientists have told the Government a badger slaughter is not the answer. But the Patersons of this world don't want to listen. This is a politically motivated slaughter that will rebound on the Conservatives at the next election.Mr Liddell-Grainger should read what the EU said: in summary the Government and the farming industry have been avoiding the real issues. Badgers, to mix metaphors, are a red herring. They are NOT the primary cause of bTB spread.

NDJMILLER says...
4:34pm Fri 8 Mar 13

Not a surprising statement coming from an ex-Chairman of the Devon Countryside Alliance. In 1997 the Krebs report recommended amongst other things "The best prospect for control of TB in the British herd is to develop a cattle vaccine". So why is this vaccine still ten or fifteen years away ? If nothing has been achieved over the past fifteen years then what guarantee do we have of success over the next fifteen ?

Poppy Field says...
9:11pm Fri 8 Mar 13

So let's get this straight. The margin between the minimum and maximum number of badgers to be culled is 81. Do Defra seriously think they know so precisely how many badgers there are in this area? Especially when they have already been told that activists tampered with the surveys. And yet they have told us that if they take out too few the cull will not work, and if they take out too many, badgers could become locally extinct. This whole thing is a travesty and needs to be stopped now.

ssimples says...
9:24pm Fri 8 Mar 13

@Spectrum

Regarding the 12-16% and the untouched 84%, the 84% may be due to the badgers left behind by the highly ineffective cull carried out in the RBCT. The trial at Thornbury was much more thorough and resulted in no confirmed cases of TB for 10 years after the last badger was killed.


@NDJMILLER

Regarding vaccine progress, DEFRA's failure to stem the public's misconception over the bovine TB vaccine "panacea" is discussed in the House of Commons discussion which took place a few days ago with Professor Glyn Hewinson, the AHVLA Chief Scientist. A postscript of this discussion should become available in the next few days.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree