Column: Rachel Gilmour on the impact of High Street taxes

"The consequence is not simply financial strain for individual shops, but a continued erosion of the high streets that many communities rely upon for jobs, services and social connection" <i>(Image: Rachel Gilmour MP)</i>
"The consequence is not simply financial strain for individual shops, but a continued erosion of the high streets that many communities rely upon for jobs, services and social connection" (Image: Rachel Gilmour MP)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Town centres and high streets are the beating heart of communities across the country, writes Rachel Gilmour MP.

Their importance is felt most keenly in rural areas, where the services, opportunities and sense of connection they provide extend far beyond employment and retail.

Cafés create spaces for social interaction, while something as simple as strolling through town and window shopping with friends and family remains an important part of community life.

High streets are more than places to spend money; they foster belonging, shape local identity and are a source of pride for the communities they serve.

While charities benefit from certain VAT exemptions that are unavailable to most businesses, they are far from immune to the pressures facing Britain’s high streets.

The British Heart Foundation plans to close 150 branches by March 2028 despite Britain’s second-hand market expanding £8.8bn annually.

In part, this reflects the rise of online resale platforms such as Vinted and Depop, which divert high-quality donations directly to peer-to-peer transactions.

Of course, these platforms offer an opportunity for individuals to make extra money on the side, which in this economic climate it cannot be blamed.

Yet the growth of online marketplaces does not tell the whole story.

We must also ask what role declining town centres and high streets are playing in this trend.

Why would someone living in a rural community drive to their closest town, which may not even be that close, to drop off donations if that is all they are able to do?

In the past, donating clothes could be partnered with browsing shops, meeting friends for a coffee, or supporting local businesses.

As high streets lose shops, service and footfall, that incentive is steadily disappearing.

The result is a vicious cycle.

Fewer visitors mean fewer customers, fewer donations, and less investment, leading to further closures and decline.

If people no longer have a reason to visit their local high street, it is hardly surprising that they are also finding fewer reasons to donate their old clothes.

Britain's charity shops are facing mounting financial pressures as consumer habits continue to shift towards online resale platforms.

At the same time, they must contend with rising fixed operating costs, including rent, energy bills and staffing expenses.

While the increase in the National Living Wage to £13.21 has been welcomed by workers and households struggling with the cost of living, it has also created significant challenges for organisations operating on tight margins.

For charity shops, higher wage bills mean a smaller surplus is available to support charitable causes.

Yet if organisations that benefit from public goodwill, volunteer support and certain tax advantages are struggling to remain viable, the outlook for independent retailers and small businesses is even more concerning.

These businesses must absorb the same increases in labour and operating costs while competing for customers against large online retailers and digital marketplaces.

The consequence is not simply financial strain for individual shops, but a continued erosion of the high streets that many communities rely upon for jobs, services and social connection.

Small and medium-sized businesses have increasingly been backed into a corner, facing many of the same pressures alongside additional financial burdens.

If charities that benefit from VAT exemptions are struggling to remain viable, what does that say about businesses that must pay it?

VAT is only one of the many challenges confronting small businesses, yet it appeared to be one of the government's only responses to supporting the high street in the 2026 autumn Budget.

While measures on VAT may provide some relief, they do little to address the wider pressures that businesses face, including rising wage costs, higher energy bills, increasing rents, and weakening consumer confidence.

Without a more comprehensive strategy, many independent businesses will continue to question not only their ability to grow, but their ability to survive.

The chancellor delivered the Budget against a backdrop of global economic uncertainty, a situation that appears only to be intensifying.

While the government's decision to reduce business rates by 20 per cent from April 2027 for thousands of pubs, social clubs and live music venues was welcomed by many, it falls short of Labour's pledge to fundamentally reform a business rates system that has long been criticised for disadvantaging high street businesses.

For years, independent retailers have argued that they shoulder a disproportionate share of the burden, while large multinational corporations with extensive online operations have been able to compete under a very different set of cost pressures.

Business rates relief may offer some short-term breathing space, but it does little to address the structural challenges facing town centres.

The Liberal Democrats are calling for a review of the cumulative impact of taxation on the high street, alongside action to improve access to competitive energy bills.

These are the kinds of reforms that recognise the challenges businesses face.

If we want town centres that are safe, sustainable and full of opportunity, we must do more than manage decline.

We must create the conditions for businesses, charities and communities to prosper together.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos